bclerdx

请问下,中日与日美之间的海缆或线路目前拥堵吗?

  •  
  •   bclerdx · Jul 29, 2019 · 6105 views
    This topic created in 2657 days ago, the information mentioned may be changed or developed.
    @hlz0812
    请问下,中日与日美之间的海缆或线路目前拥堵吗?
    49 replies  •  2019-08-05 12:34:45 +08:00
    hlz0812
    hlz0812
    Jul 29, 2019 via Android
    1
    海缆不堵,线路看对接运营商
    CernetBoom
    CernetBoom
    Jul 30, 2019 via Android
    2
    海缆没有什么堵不堵的,你买多少波就是多少波,堵的只是你的骨干网,TPE 什么的照样还一堆没点亮
    bclerdx
    bclerdx
    OP
    Jul 30, 2019 via Android
    3
    @hlz0812 Dia
    @CernetBoom 还有线路,对吧。
    hlz0812
    hlz0812
    Jul 30, 2019 via iPhone
    4
    @bclerdx dia 跟商宽差不多,也是走公网
    tia
    tia
    Jul 31, 2019
    5
    联通到 ijj 现在很稳 波动不会超过 10ms
    tia
    tia
    Jul 31, 2019
    6
    @tia #5 iij
    bclerdx
    bclerdx
    OP
    Jul 31, 2019 via Android
    7
    @tia 什么波动?
    hlz0812
    hlz0812
    Jul 31, 2019 via iPhone
    8
    @tia iij 延迟是稳,但是高峰期丢包严重,速度貌似可以跑的起来,G 口的 iij 晚上到联通多线程跑 150M 左右
    bclerdx
    bclerdx
    OP
    Jul 31, 2019 via Android
    9
    @hlz0812 单线程呢。
    bclerdx
    bclerdx
    OP
    Jul 31, 2019 via Android
    10
    @hlz0812 从国内测试高峰期么?
    hlz0812
    hlz0812
    Jul 31, 2019 via iPhone
    11
    @bclerdx 单线程 2M
    hlz0812
    hlz0812
    Jul 31, 2019 via iPhone
    12
    @bclerdx iij 卖给不同 idc 的貌似优先级也不一样,同样走 iij 的也有的快有的慢,联通到韩国的线路比较好,韩国三家的线路联通高峰期也不慢
    bclerdx
    bclerdx
    OP
    Aug 1, 2019
    13
    @hlz0812 目前似乎还是中国电信走上海或北京的出口到日本或美国 NTT 的线路各种丢包,走 HK NTT 的线路会好些吧?
    bclerdx
    bclerdx
    OP
    Aug 1, 2019
    14
    @hlz0812 完了,刚测了一些,中国电信走广州、北京出口的到日本东京炸了,走上海电信到 NTT 的到是很正常。。联通线路走 HK NTT 一切正常。
    hlz0812
    hlz0812
    Aug 1, 2019 via iPhone
    15
    @bclerdx 你得换 cn2 才能走那个点,上海 ntt 连 20Mbps 都跑不到,IIJ 这种爆炸线路刚测了下到电信都能 270 多 Mbps
    bclerdx
    bclerdx
    OP
    Aug 1, 2019
    16
    @hlz0812 请问能跑多少兆,您用什么方式测试的,谢谢~
    bclerdx
    bclerdx
    OP
    Aug 1, 2019
    17
    @hlz0812 可问题的关键就是丢包啊,丢的厉害。我受不了了(电信 与 NTT 之间),已经吐槽给 NTT 那边了,看看反馈结果吧。
    CernetBoom
    CernetBoom
    Aug 1, 2019 via Android
    18
    @bclerdx 4134 没有 2914 在香港的互联,和 9293 完全是两个东西,首先你得是 NTT 的客户,其次要是这样有用那 NTT N 年前就扩容了
    hlz0812
    hlz0812
    Aug 1, 2019
    19
    @bclerdx 走 ntt 的线路挂代理,然后在国内电脑上跑 speedtest,7-10Mbps 左右。这个已经是极限带宽了,看视频的话几乎就 50KB/s,本地 1000M 宽带
    bclerdx
    bclerdx
    OP
    Aug 1, 2019
    20
    @CernetBoom 为什么是 NTT 不扩容,而不是 AS4134 不扩容呢?
    hlz0812
    hlz0812
    Aug 1, 2019
    21
    @bclerdx NTT 买电信的带宽,不付钱电信还能求人家买?还是免费送人家?
    hlz0812
    hlz0812
    Aug 1, 2019
    22
    Testing from Amazon.com (13.112.)...
    Retrieving speedtest.net server list...
    Retrieving information for the selected server...
    Hosted by China Telecom JiangSu Branch (Suzhou) [2055.63 km]: 53.318 ms
    Testing download speed................................................................................
    Download: 103.69 Mbit/s
    Testing upload speed................................................................................................
    Upload: 108.25 Mbit/s


    Testing from ...
    Retrieving speedtest.net server list...
    Retrieving information for the selected server...
    Hosted by China Telecom JiangSu Branch (Suzhou) [2049.91 km]: 414.432 ms
    Testing download speed................................................................................
    Download: 118.56 Mbit/s
    Testing upload speed................................................................................................
    Upload: 36.63 Mbit/s

    第一个 aws 连国内测速,第二个 IIJ 连国内测速,这东西也不太准,大概看看就行
    bclerdx
    bclerdx
    OP
    Aug 1, 2019
    23
    @hlz0812 恩,就是做一个基本的参考。不够这速度也挺流弊的。另外,顺嘴问一下,这个东西是什么工具弄的?自己搭服务器,然后安装 linux 程序?
    bclerdx
    bclerdx
    OP
    Aug 1, 2019
    24
    @hlz0812 你的意思是说 NTT 买电信的是回程带宽不够?电信买 NTT 的去程带宽是足额的?
    CernetBoom
    CernetBoom
    Aug 1, 2019 via Android
    25
    @bclerdx 买带宽是对等的
    hlz0812
    hlz0812
    Aug 2, 2019 via Android
    26
    @bclerdx 买的服务器
    justs0o
    justs0o
    Aug 2, 2019
    27
    @bclerdx 世界加钱可及
    txydhr
    txydhr
    Aug 2, 2019
    28
    @hlz0812 ntt 不是 T1 运营商么?咋还付钱买带宽了😂
    hlz0812
    hlz0812
    Aug 2, 2019 via Android
    29
    @txydhr 电信亚太地区不管你 t 几都是收费,欧美才有免费的,pccw 也是 t1,亚洲带宽还不是要买电信的,所以 pccw,telstra 什么的都把直连带宽拿来卖,不然给你绕美国的 free peer 去
    bclerdx
    bclerdx
    OP
    Aug 2, 2019 via Android
    30
    @hlz0812 不是说延迟高,速度照样跑起来嘛,只要不丢包就行。中国电信摆什么臭架子啊。联通就很好呀。
    hlz0812
    hlz0812
    Aug 2, 2019
    31
    @bclerdx 关键是免费的口子就那么大,而且免费接口上的用户量还远远大于收费端口的用户量,根本不可能快的起来。像那种买了电信 20G 以上带宽的 IDC 或者运营商,往电信高峰期都可以跑 300Mbps 以上。Tier1 运营商高峰期到电信基本都是堵死的,除了 pccw 这种买的带宽比较多,而且还不低价卖给 IDC 的,像 cogent、telia、level3 这种的哪个不堵?这些 Tier1 运营商下游客户太多了,他们到中国的带宽根本支撑不住那么多流量。说真的只要不是烂大街的线路,到中国就算只有 10G 体验都不差。
    电信到 IIJ 10G,联通到 IIJ 10G
    电信到 softbank 40G,联通估计 30G 的样子,KDDI 应该也差不多
    CernetBoom
    CernetBoom
    Aug 2, 2019 via Android
    32
    @txydhr Tier 1 是 Peer Only,电信卖的是 Paid Peer

    @hlz0812 电信在亚洲就没有上游,不然照样要给钱
    Telia 的带宽不多? Level 3 和 Cogent 是电信的上游
    IIJ 还不差?

    @bclerdx 联通又 70-80%丢包了
    hlz0812
    hlz0812
    Aug 2, 2019 via iPhone
    33
    @CernetBoom telia 带宽虽然不少,有时候回程走 telia 的机房多了还是堵,基本上就是那几家大的 idc 把路由调哪家回程哪家就炸。IIJ 白天还好,ntt 是 24 小时堵,我都怀疑是不是故意搞成这样了,半夜 3 点起来看也是那个水平
    CernetBoom
    CernetBoom
    Aug 2, 2019 via Android
    34
    @hlz0812 NTT 早上 3-7 点还正常
    hlz0812
    hlz0812
    Aug 2, 2019 via Android
    35
    @CernetBoom 好几年前上海到 129.250.66.61 低峰期只有 30ms 出头,现在貌似 80 起步
    CernetBoom
    CernetBoom
    Aug 2, 2019 via Android
    36
    @hlz0812 现在也有 31 的时候
    bclerdx
    bclerdx
    OP
    Aug 2, 2019
    37
    @hlz0812 说反了吧?是 IIJ 到中国电信 10GB、IIJ 到中国联通 10GB、Softbank 到中国电信 40GB、Softbank 到到中国联通估计 30GB 的样子,KDDI 到中国联通也差不多。
    xxq2112
    xxq2112
    Aug 2, 2019 via iPhone
    38
    @bclerdx 不都是一个意思吗?难道你家到电信局只要上行不要下行吗?
    txydhr
    txydhr
    Aug 2, 2019
    39
    @CernetBoom
    A Tier 1 network is an Internet Protocol (IP) network that can reach every other network on the Internet solely via settlement-free interconnection (also known as settlement-free peering). Tier 1 networks can exchange traffic with other Tier 1 networks without having to pay any fees for the exchange of traffic in either direction, while some Tier 2 networks and all Tier 3 networks must pay to transmit traffic on other networks.
    不是不应该付钱么
    CernetBoom
    CernetBoom
    Aug 3, 2019 via Android
    40
    @txydhr 费用指的是 Transit Fee 是可以理解的,Tier 1 的定义是 Transit-free(无 Transit/上游)而已,不可能不存在任何费用,XC 之类的也是要钱的,如果真的照你这个定义就没 Tier 1 ISP 了,Tier 1 和 Tier 2 ISP 直接也是可以直接 Peer 的,不需要买 Transit
    txydhr
    txydhr
    Aug 3, 2019
    41
    @CernetBoom The pure definition of peering is settlement-free, also known as "bill-and-keep," or "sender keeps all," meaning that neither party pays the other in association with the exchange of traffic; instead, each derives and retains revenue from its own customers.
    CernetBoom
    CernetBoom
    Aug 3, 2019 via Android
    42
    @txydhr 那你解释一下 Paid Peering ?
    CernetBoom
    CernetBoom
    Aug 3, 2019 via Android
    43
    @txydhr
    Following an earlier post Peering into Peering , the definition of peering is settlement-free, "bill-and-keep," or "sender keeps all," meaning that neither party pays the other for the exchange of traffic.

    Based on the definition, peering appears to be free of cost. However, that doesn ’ t mean peering is completely free. There are costs involved such as co-location, power, equipment (routers and switches), capacity, cross-connects, local loop, effort to manage the peering and so on.
    CernetBoom
    CernetBoom
    Aug 3, 2019 via Android
    44
    @txydhr N Flix 在美国就是找 Comcast 和 Verizon 买的 Paid Peering(不是 Transit)了解一下
    CernetBoom
    CernetBoom
    Aug 3, 2019 via Android
    45
    @txydhr
    A Paid Peering relationship is a peering relationship but with an exchange of compensation from one party to the other.

    The compensation could take the form of $/Mbps as is the case with the more public offerings. In other cases it could be an asymmetric allocation of costs or the contribution of services of value.

    Peering 和 Transit 又不是靠付不付钱区分的好吗
    bclerdx
    bclerdx
    OP
    Aug 4, 2019
    46
    @hlz0812,我测了下,中国以外的其它地区或国家,到 NTT 都不丢包。这就如您说的是中国 ISP 与 NTT 之间谁的问题了。
    ThinkPad
    ThinkPad
    Aug 5, 2019 via iPhone
    47
    @hlz0812 移动到新加坡 DO 是 telstra 更好,还是 ntt 更好?
    hlz0812
    hlz0812
    Aug 5, 2019 via iPhone
    48
    @ThinkPad 差不多吧,移动自己骨干都炸成那样能有多好
    hlz0812
    hlz0812
    Aug 5, 2019 via iPhone
    49
    @bclerdx 韩国三家到 ntt 都炸飞了,hinet 也不见得多好。大陆 cn2 和 9929 也不见得差
    About   ·   Help   ·   Advertise   ·   Blog   ·   API   ·   FAQ   ·   Privacy   ·   Solana   ·   4080 Online   Highest 6679   ·     Select Language
    创意工作者们的社区
    World is powered by solitude
    VERSION: 3.9.8.5 · 54ms · UTC 01:07 · PVG 09:07 · LAX 17:07 · JFK 20:07
    ♥ Do have faith in what you're doing.